PJ’s Steakhouse Kitchen Nightmares Update (PJ’s Grill) – Open Or Closed?

Is PJ's Steakhouse still open?

Current Status: >> CLOSED <<
(keep reading to learn what happened)

Season: 4 | View All Season 4 Episodes
Original Episode Air Date: February 4, 2011
PJ's Steakhouse Address: 73-11 Yellowstone Blvd Forest Hills, NY 11375
PJ's Steakhouse Kitchen Nightmares Update

Episode Recap

PJ’s Steakhouse, later renamed PJ’s Grill, was a Forest Hills, New York (Queens) restaurant featured on Season 4 of Kitchen Nightmares. Though the PJ’s Steakhouse Kitchen Nightmares episode aired in February 2011, the actual filming and visit from Gordon Ramsay took place much earlier in March 2010. It was Episode 3 of Season 4.

P.J.’s Steakhouse is owned by husband and wife duo Joe and Madalyn. The restaurant is located in luxurious Forest Hills, which is located in Queens New York.

They opened the restaurant in honor of Joe’s brother PJ who died, which is a nice thing to do.

However, they have invested close to $2,000,000.00 into the restaurant, so they have an incredible amount riding on the success of this restaurant.

They serve different meat dishes. Joe and Madelyn have no prior experience in the restaurant business as Joe had previously worked in construction.

As a result, the restaurant is losing money and definitely needs help from Gordon Ramsay.

Gordon enters the restaurant and notices there is no one operating the desk.

He finally locates the owner seated at the bar. His wife, Madelyn and the head chef are also eventually found.

Gordon quickly realizes that Joe has no feeling for the restaurant business, which makes sense given he lacks prior experience.

As Gordon sits down to dine, he notices that the restaurant is empty.

For a steakhouse, P.J.’s Steakhouse only offers two cuts of steak, which is super weird. The restaurant lacks a porterhouse and a New York strip. Why call it a steakhouse if you’re not going to focus on steak?

Colin, Gordon’s server, greets him, and Gordon orders crab cakes, roasted garlic ravioli, and filet mignon.

The crab cakes arrive first, and Gordon doesn’t like their presentation immediately.

He also finds plastic pieces mixed in with the crab, which is obviously not a good sign.

The steak is slightly better than the crabs but is still tough. Gordon calls the ravioli disgusting.

He now understands why the restaurant is so empty even though there is a ton of foot traffic outside. 

Gordon confronts the chef, who is unhappy about Gordon’s comments, and a fight ensues.

The owners refuse to take any responsibility for the state of the restaurant. Frustrated, Gordon leaves the restaurant. 

Gordon sits down with Madelyn to discuss Joe’s brother’s death and the restaurant’s situation.

She informs him the restaurant only makes $4,000.00 a week and requires $17,000.00 to stay open.

They even had to sell their self-designed dream home to keep the restaurant dream alive. 

Gordon, who now has a better understanding of Joe, watches dinner service.

The kitchen becomes overwhelmed. The wait time for food is astronomical, and there are hungry customers.

Gordon learns from Madelyn that it usually takes up to two hours to serve a meal. 

Gordon then goes and checks the storage area. He finds moldy fruit and vegetables. Gordon is disgusted and informs the staff to throw everything out and get to cleaning.

During the dinner service, Gordon records locals and gets many negative reviews about P.J.’s Steakhouse.

Gordon comes for another dinner service and throws in special dishes like a mixed grill platter.

He puts Madelyn in charge and warns Joe to stay away from the bar.

The first specialty dish is sent back for being too cold. The head chef, Eric, gets frustrated and walks out. Without a chef, they have no choice but to shut down the restaurant. 

As part of his efforts to revamp PJ’s Steakhouse, Gordon gives the restaurant a brand new look. The interior has family pictures of Joe and his brother PJ. The restaurant really honors his memory in honor of PJ Gordon introducing an Irish stew.

Gordon also helps the restaurant find a new chef, Mark, and general manager, Edna.

For the final piece, Gordon renames PJ’s Steakhouse to PJ’s Grill. Given that the restaurant only served a few steak dishes, it seems like it makes a lot more sense to call it PJ’s Grill, so I certainly agree with Gordon’s decision here.

PJ's Steakhouse Update - What Happened Next?

Now that we’ve recapped the PJ’s Steakhouse Kitchen Nightmares, let’s talk about how things fared for the newly named PJ’s Grill once Gordon left the building.

Is PJ’s Steakhouse still open?

PJ’s Steakhouse closed in May 2010, which was just a few weeks after the episode was filmed and long before the episode aired on TV.

The old PJ’s Steakhouse location is now occupied by a restaurant called Manor Oktoberfest, which was a four-star rating on its Yelp page.

Why did PJ’s Steakhouse close?

PJ’s Steakhouse closed because the debt load was just too high. Gordon Ramsay didn’t really have a chance to save the restaurant because it had already lost so much money.

The fact that it closed just a few weeks after Gordon’s visit demonstrates this.

What happened to the PJ’s Steakhouse owners?

After PJ’s Steakhouse closed, the owners went back to their prior careers in the construction industry. As far as we know, they’re done with the restaurant business.

What happened to Chef Eric from PJ’s Steakhouse?

Unfortunately, Eric doesn’t seem to have much of an online presence so we have no idea what happened to him after the PJ’s Grill Kitchen Nightmares episode.

If anyone knows anything, please leave a comment!

👉 Read other Season 4 updates:

More Information


What did you think about the PJ's Steakhouse episode of Kitchen Nightmares? I'd love it if you shared your thoughts on the episode in the comments below!

You can also click the buttons below to share this post!

And don't forget to check out all of the other Kitchen Nightmares updates.

Watch Kitchen Nightmares Episodes at Amazon

Last updated: 2022-01-03 06:38

9 thoughts on “PJ’s Steakhouse Kitchen Nightmares Update (PJ’s Grill) – Open Or Closed?”

All comments are the sole opinion of the commenter and are not endorsed by RealityTVUpdates.

  1. In my opinion you are just a pompous person, Gordon. You should not go around acting as if you are a better chef than someone else. Because not everyone cooks the same. Stop judging books by its cover.

  2. “Stop judging books by its cover” I will need to rewatch this episode, but I swear that is EXACTLY what Eric says on the show! Lmao! Pathetic, shifting the blame onto Chef Ramsay, you’re probably still wearing the same smock from the episode you dirty fubber!

    BTW I have been reading about every episode after watching them and I love the amount of information and links you share on this site to give us the details we are looking for in 1 spot. Thank you

    • Thank you! I’m glad you find it helpful. I’m working on making all of the updates more detailed as much as possible.

  3. I’ve been re watching the season’s of this and Hotel Nightmare. Loving this site for all the updates! Makes you feel that much more about them. Thank You for your research and sharing with us


Leave a Comment

Share to...